DOWNBEAT ***** (5-stars) – Fred Alkyer
There is something compelling in the way that Maria Schneider tells a story. Her multi-award-winning album Data Lords from 2020 warned of a world being taken over by technology and big data. It was breathtaking, full of inspired composition and musicianship. Data Lords won DownBeat’s Album of the Year for both the Readers and Critics polls in 2021, and Schneider was named Composer and Arranger of the Year. The Maria Schneider Orchestra was named Large Ensemble of the Year, too. Schneider’s latest work, American Crow, serves as an extension of Data Lords. It’s an EP that clocks in at around 30 minutes, with two versions of the title song, and it is well worth every minute of listening.
“American Crow” as a composition delivers a fascinating mix of cacophony and quiet, demonstrating “the toxicity of our present social discourse that’s devolved into an impenetrable knot of curated rage,” as Schneider says in the work’s accompanying “visual narrative” on YouTube. That “video,” a fine piece of filmography, leads with a quote by the ancient philosopher Epictetus: “We have two ears and one mouth so that we can listen twice as much as we speak” — something that seems like a lost art. And that’s the true essence of Schneider’s vision. She asks for listening, understanding, care. Through her music, she asks us to come together. She is a unifying force.
“American Crow” hits hard from the downbeat, the band blaring, the trumpet section imitating the sound of crows cawing. From that chaos — and a quick side note, even chaos sounds beautiful in Schneider’s hands — the mood of the tune turns to a meditative lament featuring Mike Rodriguez’s tear-rendering trumpet work. Schneider, like her heroes before, has mastered the art of writing for her individual band members, all of whom have been with the ensemble for most of its three-decade career. In this case, it’s Rodriguez who enjoys the featured role. And his emotionally charged playing is simply devastating. Read full review
“Data Lords” . . . is her magnum opus, a riveting, remarkably intense double album, as profound as modern-day instrumental music gets. Link to article
- MINNEAPOLIS STAR TRIBUNE – Jon BreamNow it's finally here, in the form of a magnificent double album, Data Lords . . . it parses into thematic halves, "The Digital World" and, as an antidote, "The Natural World." On the whole and in the details, it amounts to the most daring work of Schneider's career, which sets the bar imposingly high. This is music of extravagant mastery, and it comes imbued with a spirit of risk. Link to article
- NPR.com – Nate Chinen“The Digital World” emerges as her manifesto against everything that limits the expressive range of the human spirit. “The Natural World” becomes a summarizing afterword in Schneider’s musical autobiography that illustrates the natural forces that keep her creative compass pointing true north. Link to article
- The Arts Fuse –– Allen MichieData Lords: Schneider’s craft and judgment are such that music in the eerie, dystopian world has the marvellous feeling for structure, pacing and often sheer beauty that listeners who know Schneider’s music will be expecting. . . .
There are instrumental glories throughout this album, but the work of the low brass both as section and as individuals is quite unbelievable and is caught exceptionally well on the recording. Whereas Wagner once said “don’t look at the trombones, it only encourages them", I had the sense that Maria Schneider must keep looking at the trombones a lot. And they certainly deliver here. Link to article
- TheArtsDesk.com – Sebastian ScotneyWith Data Lords – a steeliness and even bleakness now shares a stage with her familiar pastoral side. . . . The inner tensions behind this compelling session promise a revealing new phase in Schneider's remarkable work. Link to article
- THE GUARDIAN – John FordhamBeyond the dualism in its format, Data Lords is a work of holistic creativity. The music of outrage and critique in the first album has all the emotion and conceptual integrity that the music of melancholy and reverence does in the second. I can’t conceive of anyone else creating this music, unless Delius has been writing with Bowie on the other side. Link to article
- THE NATION – David HajduData Lords: Disc One offers highly imaginative, revelatory, at times breathtaking music as in the title track. . . . Expect this project, at a minimum, to be a Grammy contender with perhaps historic recognition in the wings at some point. Link to article
_________________________
The Thompson Fields: “... this magnificent, nature-drunk masterpiece, one of the great jazz records period, not just one of the great recent jazz records.”
- THE BUFFALO NEWS – Jeff SimonMaria Schneider wanted to send a strong message about the threat of a mass manipulation of humanity with Data Lords. Through her high standard for meticulous composing and arranging, delivered by some of jazz’s best musicians, she gets the message across in perhaps the grandest way possible.
- SomethingElseReviews.com – S. Victor AaronThe Thompson Fields: ***** "...there is nobody more capable of harnessing emotions in music and projecting and preserving the beauty and power of the natural world in sound than Maria Schneider. She's demonstrated that time and again, and she does it once more on this awe-inspiring release."
The Thompson Fields: "This marriage of sounds, words and images is ultimately breathtaking, a testament not simply to the hipness of jazz but to the uplifting and sustaining powers of art."
- OTTAWA CITIZEN – Peter Hum"The Thompson Fields breaks through to a new level. It's her most ambitious recording, and her most accomplished; it places her in the pantheon of big-band composer-leaders, just below Ellington, Strayhorn, and Gil Evans at his very best; it's a masterpiece"
- STEREOPHILE – Fred KaplanThe Thompson Fields ***** (five stars) "Her latest album, some 10 years in the making, shows just what a supple and powerful instrument a jazz orchestra can be."
- THE TELEGRAPH – Ivan HewettThe Thompson Fields: ***** (five stars) "...a sound-world of rare eloquence ... the singularly most beautiful record I've heard this year."